Can you trust someone who promises to take responsibility but disappears when there is a problem? I don’t think so. And can we trust a large institution that announces its good intentions, then makes it impossible to find out who made a decision or how to challenge it? Again, I don’t think so.

In How can you trust me, and how can I trust you?, I argued that trust must be earned through what people and institutions actually do. Accountability is the part of that argument I want to examine this week. It works between two people, and it works between a society and the institutions that exercise power in its name. When either level fails, the other becomes harder to sustain. None of us wants to live in a world without trust. We should be equally worried about a world in which nobody has to answer for what they do.

First, a distinction. Responsibility can mean that a task belongs to me. Accountability means that I can be asked what I did with it, by someone whose questions matter. Mark Bovens, a scholar of public administration, describes a relationship in which an actor must explain and justify their conduct, a forum can question and judge it, and consequences may follow. That sounds formal, but you can recognise it at the kitchen table: “You said you would do this. What happened, and what are we going to do now?”

Who can ask the difficult question?

The kitchen-table version becomes harder when the person who made the promise controls the records, the rules and the room in which questions can be asked. That is why accountability on a societal scale needs more than leaders with admirable personal qualities. It needs durable arrangements through which people can find out what happened and influence what happens next.

Daron Acemoglu and James A. Robinson’s Why Nations Fail contrasts institutions that spread political and economic opportunity with institutions that concentrate power and its rewards. If the powerful can bend law and policy to protect themselves, being told that everyone is accountable means very little. Rule of law, independent scrutiny and meaningful political participation give a person outside the inner circle some capacity to demand an answer.

Their The Narrow Corridor adds a productive tension. A state must be strong enough to protect rights and provide services, while a mobilised society must remain strong enough to constrain the state. The authors call the result a “shackled Leviathan”. It does not stay shackled simply because someone wrote a constitution. Courts, journalists, unions, community groups, voters and public servants have to use and defend the means of scrutiny. Accountability is a continuing relationship, not a certificate awarded to a government at its founding.

Acemoglu’s more recent What Happened to Liberal Democracy? asks what happens when that relationship loses a large part of its public. If workers experience declining opportunity and little political voice, a formal right to vote may feel thin. He argues for a wider democratic coalition grounded in shared prosperity, good jobs, effective public services and stronger local and workplace organisation. Material conditions matter because people need time, security and collective capacity to make their questions count.

We can make this practical. A public decision should leave a trail of reasons and evidence. The people affected need a usable way to challenge it. Independent bodies need the authority and resources to investigate, and officials need to respond to findings with changes that can be checked. The OECD’s work on trust in public institutions reinforces the importance of fairness, integrity, openness and responsiveness, especially people’s sense that they have a say. Publishing a report is a beginning; answering its questions is the work.

I am not suggesting that every disappointing outcome proves a failure of accountability. Sometimes an honest, competent institution makes a decision we dislike. The test is whether it can give reasons, hear a challenge, acknowledge an error and accept a consequence when it has failed. That test also applies to institutions smaller than a state. The question is how to make it work inside a large organisation without having every decision wait for permission from the top.

Can a large organisation answer for its work?

Stan McChrystal’s Team of Teams arose from the difficulties of coordinating specialised teams in a fast-changing conflict. An organisation could contain excellent teams and still fail because one group did not know what another had learned. Information moved slowly up and down separate chains. The answer was to create a common purpose, share a much wider picture of the situation, build trust across boundaries and let the people closest to events make informed decisions.

A daily operations and intelligence forum brought dispersed teams into a shared conversation, while connections between units helped information travel where it was needed. That was more than a new meeting. People had to explain what they knew, expose an assumption to other specialists and see how their actions affected a common mission. Leaders had to give up the comfort of personally approving every choice while remaining answerable for the conditions in which choices were made. Shared information made delegated authority more accountable, not less.

That model can fail if “one mission” means that nobody outside the organisation gets to question the mission or its methods. A military task force, a business and a public service have different obligations to the people they affect. Internal speed and alignment are valuable, but they do not replace external oversight, lawful limits or an avenue for a person harmed by a decision to be heard. The forum for accountability must extend beyond the people who share the organisation’s goals.

Chris Fussell and C. W. Goodyear’s One Mission turns the broad idea into an operating practice. Their approach begins by clarifying the common mission and establishing a regular rhythm of forums where teams exchange useful information. Relationships across silos let people ask for help before a problem turns into a crisis. Leaders clarify the boundaries of local decision-making, then allow people with the relevant knowledge to act. Teams return to the forum with what happened, what they learned and what now needs to change.

Imagine a hospital in which an appointment system repeatedly leaves patients without essential information. One team sees missed calls, another sees a queue, and a third hears from distressed patients. A shared forum makes the pattern visible. A named team can fix the message and test the result; the patients’ experience tells everyone whether the fix actually worked. This is my example, not a case from the books, but it shows the principle: visibility, decision rights, feedback and correction have to form a loop. An impressive dashboard cannot answer a patient’s question on its own.

The design of that loop matters because fear can silence the information we most need. Amy Edmondson’s research on psychological safety distinguishes the freedom to speak candidly from low standards. We need both candour and accountability for good work. If every mistake is met with humiliation, people hide it; if nothing is expected or followed through, candour has little practical effect. The aim is a place where someone can raise a concern early and everyone still has to help address it.

The person inside the system

A new forum or reporting line will not speak for itself. Someone has to decide to bring unwelcome information into the room. McChrystal’s memoir, My Share of the Task, is useful here because it places a career of institutional change alongside the leaders he learned from, the mistakes he had to face and the controversies he could not simply manage away. The title itself asks a good question: what share of this outcome was mine to influence?

In a Georgetown University interview about his later book, On Character, McChrystal describes his resignation from command in Afghanistan as painful, and accepts responsibility for the situation in which he found himself. We do not have to treat that account as the final judgment on every controversy of his career to see the point. Accountability begins when a leader stops pretending that their intentions settle the question of their impact.

In On Character: Choices That Define a Life, he describes character as convictions joined to the discipline to live them. The accumulation of ordinary choices matters as much as the dramatic moment. That makes accountability a way of developing character: we compare what we meant to do with what we actually did, hear how others experienced it and adjust tomorrow’s practice. It is uncomfortable because we are answerable in several roles at once—to colleagues, family, the people our work affects and ourselves. Those obligations may conflict. Saying so honestly is more useful than claiming that one decision satisfied everyone.

I have found, in mentoring and professional work, that “I meant well” often starts the conversation I most need to have. The important question that follows is: “what did another person experience because of my decision, what did I miss, and what can I repair?” Accepting a question about our work does not make us smaller. It gives us a chance to become more capable of doing the work.

Courage needs compassion and a check on power

Eric Greitens’s The Heart and the Fist makes a case for joining compassion to courage in service of others. His Resilience grew from letters to a fellow veteran and asks what we can take responsibility for when circumstances feel overwhelming. The connection to accountability is insightful: compassion makes us notice the person who will live with the outcome, while courage helps us face the answer when we have caused harm or need to challenge someone more powerful. Responsibility for our response is real, even when we are not responsible for everything that happened to us.

Greitens’s own rise and fall makes this a difficult example to use without qualification. He became governor of Missouri and resigned in 2018 amid allegations of personal misconduct and a legislative investigation; criminal charges were later dismissed, while a Missouri House committee described a complainant’s account as credible. The Missouri State Archives’ record of his governorship sets out that sequence. Dismissal of a charge does not resolve every question of conduct, and I do not know his private reckoning. His books can still put a useful standard before us, but their author is subject to it too. We should neither excuse serious allegations as a mere mistake nor pretend that an imperfect writer cannot have expressed an important idea.

The lesson is larger than one person. Courage without attention to others can become domination; compassion without the willingness to act can leave people unsupported. And neither virtue, even sincerely held, substitutes for answering a specific question about a specific decision. Accountability gives admirable words an encounter with consequences.

So where could we begin? In a relationship or a small team, name the promise and who may ask how it went. Make it safe to say, early, that something is going wrong. After a decision, ask the affected people what they experienced; explain what you learned and follow through on a correction. In a large institution, connect the teams that hold different pieces of the same problem, give frontline people room to act and maintain an independent route for those outside to challenge the outcome. As citizens, we can use and defend the courts, civic groups, journalism and representative processes that make power answerable.

We will not become perfectly accountable, and no institution will stop making mistakes. The aspiration is more demanding and more achievable: keep the chain between a decision, an explanation, a fair question and a real correction intact. That chain lets a person grow, a system learn and a society retain the capacity to trust. When someone asks, “Who answers for this?”, we should be able to find a person, a process and a way forward.

Thank you for reading to the end. If you got value from this, please share with your network and sign up below for updates. It really helps, and it makes me smile.